His songs cannot be translated without bodies and actions. Like Toni Morrison’s words, like Tuka’s verse, his songs are the songs of the human cry. You cannot separate his songs from his body. While the portrayal of Gaddar is fine as a Naxalite or a Dalit activist, we need to be open to his other identities. In the future, one may study his songs as giving voice and dignity to objects. He may equally find his identity with rivers and forests. One cannot deny the different identities and belongings of Gaddar, but that is not the end. He was infinite. Gaddar joined the legacy of Kabir, Tuka and Billie Holiday. “Do you think if you will not write about me, I will be finished? I ask you to go away and not write. My people will remember me. Could you stop people from remembering Kabir and Tuka? Can you erase their histories? It will never happen,” an angry balladeer told me one day.