It is commonly supported by historical evidence that many ruling or ‘ashraf families’ of Muslims from the erstwhile states of Awadh, Hyderabad, Junagadh and principalities of Murshidabad etc migrated to Pakistan because they were unable to take relegation from ruler to ruled. This was inevitable in the Jinnah-dominated Muslim discourse in the post-1920s Congress years. However, once in Punjabi Pakistan, they were equally unable to hold on to their tenuous past, becoming a dominated subculture termed as Mohajirs or migrants. In India, the ensuing hiatus in Muslim political leadership fell into the lap of fundamentalist mullahs. What Muslims gained in espousing a schizophrenic votebank identity, they lost out in mainstream opportunity. This realisation is partly generating the momentum for a Muslim Spring that Hasan speaks of. The author authenticates this by quoting voices of Muslim youth across a cross-section. It should act as a timely precursor to generate further academic research.