I became a ‘Babu’ in 1956 when I joined the IAS and Uttar Pradesh became my cadre. In those days, we were taught that a civil servant should be politically neutral, and always give correct advice without fear or favour. My early years in UP reinforced my belief in this maxim. I will never forget one case where the chief minister, the late C.B. Gupta, wanted to promote someone, and I objected to his recommendation thrice in writing. My superiors, including the chief secretary, supported me. Each time, the CM overruled us. Far from being transferred, I was promoted in turn. From 1968-73, I was on deputation to Jammu and Kashmir. The ministers there were perfect gentlemen, very courteous and treated civil servants with respect. I could take action against forest lessees, many with strong political affiliations. The contrast was apparent in the early 1990s, when I was MD of Maruti Udyog. My failure to ‘oblige’ some of those in power led to my having to fight CBI cases for the next 20 years, with the government moving the Company Law Board to declare me unfit to be a director. The performance and success of Maruti became irrelevant. Any surprise, then, that public sector companies should underperform?