Low Vaccinations, Negligence In Home Isolation: What Central Covid Team That Visited Kerala Found

Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya on Tuesday said the Centre’s team headed by the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) had returned from Kerala and submitted its report, which mentions low vaccinations and strained healthcare infrastructure as problem points amid rising Covid cases in the state. In its report to the Union health ministry, the team said contact tracing of COVID-19 patients in the state is low, home isolation guidelines are not being followed and the number of tests conducted to detect the infection is showing a downward trend.

Mandaviya added that he had talked to Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan over the phone and discussed the matter. “I have also written a letter to CM Vijayan Pinarayi ji for taking more proactive measures and precautions to control the ongoing situation in Kerala. I have sought the State’s cooperation in managing the situation and have assured Central Government’s complete support," he said in a tweet.

According to official sources, the report pointed out that people are becoming more complacent regarding Covid-appropriate behaviour and highlighted the need for ramping up vaccination.

Dr Sujeet Singh, Director, National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC), P Ravindran, former DDG, Dr SK Jain, Advisor (PH) NCDC, Dr K Regu, Additional Director, Kozhikode branch of the NCDC, Dr Pranay Verma, Joint Director, NCDC, and Dr Ruchi Jain, Public Health Specialist, Regional Office of Health and Family Welfare, Thiruvananthapuram, were part of the central multi-disciplinary team. 

To increase the number of districts to be covered, the team members who reached Kerala on August 30 were divided into two groups -- one for the southern districts and another for the northern districts.

The first group reviewed Alappuzha, Kollam, Pathanamthitta and Thiruvananthapuram districts, while the second group visited Malappurum, Kozhikode, Kannur and Kasargod.

According to the observations by the second group, the trajectory of cases is on an upward trend with a test positivity rate (TPR) of 17.26 per cent. There is no active surveillance or notified containment zones with perimeter control and the testing is declining with an RT-PCR-RAT ratio of 20:80. 

"The case-contact ratio is 1:1.5, which is abysmally low. More than 90.12 per cent of the Covid patients are under home isolation and the guidelines on isolation and quarantine are not followed. There is a limited monitoring of the prescribed parameters to identify early warning signs," an official source quoted from the report.

The vaccination coverage for the eligible population is low as compared to the other districts, the report stated.

According to the observations made by the first group, containment and Micro-CZs are not made according to established GoI guidelines and in most cases, there are no surrounding buffer zones.

The number of contacts traced per positive case is quite low. In a few districts like Thiruvananthapuram, less than two contacts have been traced per positive case. Usually only household contacts are targeted.

Most Category-A patients prefer home isolation. However, in many instances, proper quarantine practices are not followed by these patients due to which intra-house transmission is high and this may be leading to the formation of clusters, the report stated.

According to the report, the death audit is being conducted for all fatalities suspected due to COVID-19. However, deaths are reported in the state bulletin on the day the audit is completed rather than on the dates when they occurred.

It was indicated by state officials that due to effective home isolation and containment strategies after the first wave of Covid, the population remained largely unexposed.

This was also suggested by a recently conducted sero-surveillance study by the ICMR. Kerala occupied the last rank in the study, with only about 44 per cent of its population showing antibodies against Covid.

The central team has recommended that the strategy of categorising panchayats needs to be re-examined and RAT testing at an expanded level should be implemented.

The number of RT-PCR tests also needs to be increased.

The number of contacts traced per case should also be increased, according to the recommendations.

Patients in home isolation should be closely monitored and adequate infrastructure like pulse oximeter as well as a monitoring framework should be in place. In addition, a deeper analysis needs to be undertaken regarding the number of deaths in home isolation as well as the number of people referred in a serious condition.

A system to put the entire house under quarantine may be followed. Notably, the family members of the patients should not be allowed to move out freely when their reports are due, the recommendations stated.

The option of a 14-day lockdown in wards showing a high TPR for a long time should be explored, the team has recommended.

To flatten the curve, the reproductive number should be brought down to 0.95 or lower through effective containment and control measures and containment zones need to be defined and notified on the basis of mapping of cases and contacts.

Active surveillance in the containment zones needs to established and the principle of "test-track-isolate" needs to be followed, the recommendations said.

The case contact ratio has to be at least 10-15 contacts for every case. Clusters and super-spreader events, whenever suspected or reported, should be investigated by the district-level RRT.

The report mentioned that Malappurum district needs to ensure strict compliance of the home isolation guidelines. Home isolation should be permitted only if the prescribed conditions of necessary space requirements are met. Monitoring of the clinical status and in particular, oxygen saturation needs to be strictly followed.

The hospital infrastructure of oxygen beds, ICU and ventilator beds needs to be augmented on an urgent basis. Paediatric care facilities, especially paediatric ICU beds, also need to be augmented and vaccination for the eligible population needs to be enhanced.

With PTI inputs