Tussle Between Bengal Governor And Mamata Banerjee Govt Touches New Flashpoint

The ongoing tussle between West Bengal Governor, Jagdip Dhankar, and the Mamata Banerjee government has reached a flashpoint.

The West Bengal state assembly has been suspended for two consecutive days -- Wednesday and Thursday -- for lack of business due to unavailability of six bills that are still lying with the Governor.

Dhankar says the government has not responded to the clarifications he sought before giving his nod to the bills. He says the government, instead, sent a senior government official with some clarifications.

On Tuesday, Dhankar tweeted, “As Governor I follow the script and tune of the Constitution, and cannot blindly take a call. I am neither a rubber stamp nor a post office. I am obliged to scrutinise the bills in light of the Constitution and act without delay. Concerned at the delay by government on this.”

The six bills that are awaiting his consent are: The West Bengal (Prevention of Lynching) Bill, 2019; The West Bengal State Commission for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Bill, 2019; West Bengal Lifts, Escalators and Travellators Bill, 2019; West Bengal Municipal (Amendment) Bill, 2019; West Bengal Apartment Ownership (Amendment) Bill, 2019 and The Hindi University, West Bengal Bill,  2019.

While both the state government and the Governor were blaming each other for the stalemate that has caused the sudden suspension of the House, the Governor was in for a rude shock when he went to visit the state assembly on Thursday and found the main gate, which is designated for his entry, locked. Later he was ushered in through another gate in the House precinct but could not find the Speaker or Deputy Speaker there to receive him in person.

An enraged Dhankar said he was invited by the Speaker for lunch, but that was cancelled at the last moment. "This is an insult and points towards conspiracy," he said.

He further observed that the “Assembly being adjourned does not mean it is closed”.

"The incident of the designated gate being locked has put the democratic history to shame,” he caustically remarked. Congress leader Abdul Mannan, a senior legislator, says that the government is duty-bound to answer all the queries raised by the Governor. Sujan Chakraborty, leader of the CPI-M legislative party, is also puzzled by the development.

The rift, that began in September this year, when the incumbent Governor rushed to Jadavpur University campus to ‘rescue’ union minister Babul Supriyo from the students’ agitation, has now developed into a chasm, which no side is keen to bridge. From the very beginning, Mamata’s government has had a non-cooperative attitude towards the Governor. When he visited North Bengal for a meeting with senior officials of the state administration, none turned up. Dhankar had to make do with a meeting with the local opposition leaders.

There is a pattern that unfolds whenever the Governor visits an institution of importance in the state. His visit on Thursday to Calcutta University also met with similar consequences that he faced at Assembly House.

Upon reaching the university, the Governor-Chancellor found the office of the Vice-Chancellor and the meeting room of the Senate locked. Nobody was there to receive him. Again, the university came out with an explanation that the Governor’s office had been intimated of the cancellation of the scheduled meeting of the Senate.

As the situation is building up to a boiling point, the media persons are having a field day. Dhankar is persistently communicating his woes to the media. He suspects some ‘conspiracy’ in the pattern. While both sides are keen to score brownie points, the contentious issue between the Governor and the state government is slowly developing into a constitutional crisis.