Amar Singh Chamkila, one of the greatest stage singers of Punjab who rose to fame with ‘Pehle Lalkare Nal’, was assassinated in 1988. His killing is still unsolved with many alleging the hands of Khalistani operatives who felt his songs were against their movement. Now the recent killing of rapper Shubhdeep Singh alias Sidhu Moosewala completes a full circle of Punjab’s tryst with a violent end to musicians.