The contrast could not be starker. On September 22, as Jammu observed a total shutdown called by its business community, there was not a ripple in Kashmir. The spell of silence that descended in the wake of the abrogation of Article 370 on the Valley—once the terrain of fiery protests against the government and security forces—remained unbroken. “The Jammu traders are lucky,” quips a Kashmiri businessman. “In the Valley, a call for protests would have landed a large number of people in jail.”