Hajj Deaths 2024: Who Is To Blame?

Outlook Web Desk

Disturbing Images From Hajj

The pictures and videos from Saudi Arabia show people who were undertaking their once-in-a-lifetime Hajj pilgrimage to Mecca collapsed on the side of the road or slumped in wheelchairs, apparently close to death or dead.

AP

Scorching Temperatures

Temperatures in Mecca, Islam's holiest city, rose to 51.8 degrees Celsius during the course of the annual event, which started late last week.

AP

Heat Exhaustion Cases

Sources in the Saudi Arabian Health Ministry told Reuters news agency they had recorded 2,700 cases of "heat exhaustion." 

AP

Death Toll

According to AFP news agency, which has been tallying up fatalities via different sources and countries over the past few days, the death toll has topped 1,000.

AP

Pilgrims From These Countries Have Died

Pilgrims from Egypt, Indonesia, Senegal, Jordan, Iran, Iraq, India and Tunisia have all died, their governments reported. A large number, likely over 300, came from Egypt. The Indonesian Health Ministry also reported the deaths of over 140 nationals.

AP

Who Is To Blame?

In the pilgrims' home countries, a furious debate is taking place about who is to blame.

AP

Heatwave In Saudi Arabia 

Unprecedented heatwaves in Saudi Arabia and alleged mismanagement by authorities are seen as major factors behind the high death toll.

AP

Warnings Ignored

Despite Saudi Health Ministry warnings to avoid heat exposure and stay hydrated, many pilgrims fell victim to heat stress and heatstroke.

AP

Poor Accommodation

According to several accounts, accommodation and facilities for pilgrims were poorly managed, with overcrowded tents lacking adequate cooling and sanitation facilities.

AP

Unregistered Pilgrims

While registered pilgrims have access to facilities like air conditioning and misting centres through travel agents, unregistered pilgrims lack these essential services, which may have contributed to casualties. 

AP

'Blessing To Die In The Holy City'

One reason there may be many deaths every year at the Hajj is that many pilgrims go towards the end of their life, after saving for a lifetime. Many Muslims also go in the hopes that if they die, it is during the Hajj - as it is considered to be a blessing to die and be buried in the holy city.

AP