Business

The Gen(i)e Is Out Again

The cultivation of Bt cotton, a genetically modified seed, in Gujarat opens an old can of worms

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
The Gen(i)e Is Out Again
info_icon
  • The trial data is not made public and the regulatory process is not transparent.
  • The high yields claimed by Mahyco are questionable as the crop was sown two-three months late due to delayed permission. This means that the crops were not exposed to the brunt of pest attack and hence the high yields aren't entirely due to Bt. So, this June the geac asked Mahyco to repeat its trials for another year.
  • Trials were conducted in one-acre plots though even 100-acre plots are considered to be too small for safe extrapolation from field trials to large-scale cultivation. However, this June, the geac asked Mahyco to conduct large-scale trials on 100-acre plots, which are under way.
  • Trials over two seasons were deemed sufficient. In the US trials happen over six seasons.
  • As plot sizes are small in India, it is not possible for farmers to sow non-Bt crop in a portion of his plot so that any resistance to Bt cotton could be registered and hence checked.

    Critics further point out that alternative approaches to the problem of pesticide-resistance haven't been fully explored. Says Sharma: "It is being repeatedly said that Bt cotton is a part of the integrated pest management (IPM) practices. But that ipm package has never been divulged. Scientists are not even aware of an experiment in Madhya Pradesh wherein 1,100 farmers were growing cotton without chemicals and still getting higher yields."

    This mutual distrust between activists and industry/government has made the debate even more shrill and confusing for the lay person.

    Meanwhile, Desai seems to be on the run.His being incommunicado has left many questions unanswered—origins of the seed, accomplices in the crime, irregularities with respect to other GM crops. Clearly, with the controversy over Bt cotton taking such a sordid turn, all this and more needs to be investigated in great detail. But that won't happen unless the dbt and the seed industry come clean.
  • Tags